No Compensation Means Exploitation - 2390 Words

No Compensation Means Exploitation â€Å"[T]he real scandal is not that students are getting illegally paid or recruited, it’s that two of the noble principles on which the NCAA justifies its existence-‘amateurism’ and the ‘student-athlete’ are cynical hoaxes, legalistic confections propagated by the universities so they can exploit the skills and fame of young athletes†¦The NCAA makes money, and enables universities and corporations to make money, from the unpaid labor of young athletes. (Zirin 26) The line between college and professional sports continues to blur where college sports now acts like the minor leagues for professional organizations like the NBA and the NFL. But unlike the minor leagues where players are paid to play in their respective sport, players or student-athletes in the NCAA receive $0 for playing for their school. They do however receive scholarships, some being worth up to $60,000 to pay for tuition and room and board. These athletes are able to obtain a free education through these scholarships but it is not enough. Two of the biggest sports in college athletics, football and men’s basketball, earn millions of dollars in revenue for schools around the country and for the NCAA, yet these athletes do not see one penny of it. The top coaches in these sports earn seven figure salaries with six figure bonuses depending on how well they do in the post season but the players that are generating the money are not being compensated for their efforts. In the 2014Show MoreRelatedImplicit Concerns For The Legalization Of The Organ Sale1347 Words   |  6 Pagesoverstates the monetary compensation for the organ sale and underestimates the possible role of exploitation, risks to organ sellers and other ethical questions. As a result, the sellers would not benefit as much as she states, and her argument about the bilateral reciprocal consequences for both organ sellers and buyers after legalization would be incomplete. To begin with, although MacKay discusses several factors like regulations and middleman which may influence the monetary compensation for sellers, sheRead MoreLegalizing The Sale Of Human Organs1246 Words   |  5 Pagesthe benefits of monetary compensation for sellers, and ignores the continued presence of exploitation of poor sellers, the risks of organ donations other than kidney and the moral attitudes of sellers. As a result, if the sale of organs were legal, organ sellers would not be benefiting as much as she states. Her arguments about the bilateral reciprocal results for both donors and receivers would be untenable by these implicit problems To begin with, the monetary compensation for sellers would not beRead MoreIs It Time For Rethinking America s Organ Transplant Law?1363 Words   |  6 Pagesof the National Organ Transplant Act of 1984, which prohibited the sale of human organs and almost all forms of compensation (Monti). The act was originally intended to prevent exploitation of the poor, who found that selling their own organs to the wealthy was a quick and easy way to earn large amounts of money. Over the years, it became more evident that banning organ donor compensation actually discriminated against the poor rather than protected them, by ensuring that only the wealthy could affordRead MoreThe Ncaa And The Realm Of Intercollegiate Competition1536 Words   |  7 Pagesstatement by Emmert has again sparked several conversations concerning the specifics of what defines amateurism and the exploitation of our young student athletes. The awarding of a salary to athletes is both heavily supported and strongly oppos ed by players, spectators, coaches, and collegiate administration across the country. An issue that arises when discussing exploitation is the lack of privacy an athlete receives, which is shocking in comparison to any other â€Å"normal† student at a college orRead MoreEssay on Organ Sales1478 Words   |  6 Pagesonly continuing to grow. I am going to argue that the best to solve this problem is to legalize the regulated sale of organs to better society as a whole. Organ sales should be legalized for two reasons: greater good of the society and to avoid exploitation of the poor as selling an organ could be the best option for the poor to make money. I firmly believe that organ sales should be legalized and I will explain the many arguments I have listed above. First off, the legalization of organ sales shouldRead MoreShould Surrogacy Be Legal?1712 Words   |  7 Pagessurrogacy grew by one-thousand percent, suggesting a significant amount of children was being born each year from international surrogacies† (qtd. In Permanente Bureau: 8) With such rapid growth, concerns surrounding the welfare of children, the exploitation of surrogates, and the legal consequences for intended parents are too on the rise. In large part, in consequence of such agreements being allowed to take place internationally were intended parents are attempting to use loopholes in the laws toRead MoreKarl Marx s Theory Of Human Exploitation And Alienation Under Capitalism Essay1550 Words   |  7 Pagesproperty and investments in their own name. That being said, some, such as Karl Marx, find the capitalist system dehumanizing and see a dire need for its abolition. In this paper, I will present an argument against Karl Marx’s theory of human exploitati on and alienation under capitalism. I will begin by discussing Marx’s basic beliefs on human nature. I will then use this foundation to present Marx’s argument against capitalism and how he believes it leads to human alienation. Lastly, I willRead MoreThe Modern University System Essay1307 Words   |  6 Pageswhatever career path one chooses, including careers in the academic world. Specific to academic careers, a cycle of oppression and exploitation of labor exists to prevent any one person from getting too successful, lest they challenge the system and destroy it. Academia forces its participants to work in a very individualistic, neoliberal manner which encourages exploitation of other participants and perpetuates abusive labor practices, all in an effort to preserve a structure which encourages the professionalizationRead MoreExploitation or opportunity1293 Words   |  6 PagesChina, Bangladesh or Mexico, represent exploitation or opportunity? Every exploitative relationship begins with an initial inequality that makes the taking advantage possible. In exploitative relationship the rich get richer and the poor fall further behind. - Robert Mayer Exploitation, in this case economic exploitation, can be defined as using somebody s labor, but in return giving an unfair compensation, or taking unfair advantage of laborer. Exploitation is nowadays mostly taking place inRead MoreWho Is Abused On Organ Sales?1449 Words   |  6 Pagesfacing today. The issue is lives are at stake. Lives that all are in need of one thing, in common, a good and healthy organ from a donor. There is such thing as a mutually beneficial exploitation; this is not the same as beneficial exploitation which helps one side of the problem. The mutual beneficial exploitation means that one party is exploited but both benefit from it. This is my argument. Yes it might exploit the poor rather slightly; however the overall outcome is beneficial to both sides